Cultural Appropriation

The following reposted by permission from Brendan Birth:

 BY BRENDAN BIRTH

What is… Cultural Appropriation?

When I was a senior at Dickinson College in Pennsylvania (which was in Fall 2015), a HUGE controversy erupted on campus. In short, there was an “Around the World” party at the college. At the party, a student posted on his Instagram account a photo of himself and a friend of his wearing sombreros. The photo had the caption “We swear we’ve got our green cards,” and the photo had the hashtags of #taco, #chihuahua and #tequila. In addition to the Instagram photo, there was a Facebook photo of a male student wearing a white flannel undershirt and a bandana posing with a female student at Dickinson who was wearing a sombrero at the party.[1]

To say that there was anger about the existence of the party, the social media posts, and the people involved in the party would be an understatement. The political climate in the United States was already tense at the time, with then-candidate Donald Trump surging in the polls with inflammatory rhetoric about immigrants, and particularly Mexican immigrants. Therefore, when news of this party and the social media posts from the party spread around the student body at Dickinson, there was an outpouring of fury. In particular, there was fury at the fact that instead of aiming for cultural appreciation, the party and all involved with it instead performed acts that were considered by many to be cultural appropriation.

But what is cultural appropriation?

Cultural appropriation is defined by the Oxford Dictionary as, “The unacknowledged or inappropriate adoption of the customs, practices, ideas, etc. of one people or society by members of another and typically more dominant people or society.”[2] Whether we realize it or not, cultural appropriation actually happens on an everyday basis. When, without acknowledgement, you use Arabic numerals to help you with your math, make food from other cultures, and wear a form of clothing design that comes from a culture not your own, you are performing acts of cultural appropriation.

However, it’s not those everyday instances of cultural appropriation—those instances where the cultures responsible for the numbers we use, the food we eat, and the clothes we wear are not acknowledged—that seem to get the most flack (either rightly or wrongly). Instead, it is making fun of or otherwise mocking a certain culture/group of people that gets the most flack. Such actions fit within the definition of cultural appropriation, but might also fall into the realm of another term I hear less often: cultural mockery. Cultural mockery happens when there is inappropriate misrepresentation, imitation, caricaturizing, or making fun of a culture. The “We swear we’ve got our green cards” incident at Dickinson would fall into the category of cultural mockery.

On the other hand, if we are “honoring and respecting another culture and its practices, as a way to gain knowledge and understanding,”[3] then it’s cultural appreciation. One common example I’ve seen of cultural appreciation is when someone makes the food of another culture (and not just food stereotyped as being from another culture) while explaining the history of the dish and how that dish became so important to the culture. Through that, something as simple as food can encompass not just food, but also the history of the culture (how the dish fits within the history of a culture), the types of crops that the culture relies on (the economy of the culture), and much more.

Some of us may unwittingly fall into cultural mockery—something that may happen with some frequency with the upcoming Cinco de Mayo. However, if we really want to aim to learn more about cultures outside our own, we should really strive for cultural appreciation, and for actually trying to learn more and understand more about the cultures we aren’t a part of.


[1] Click on the following link to learn about this controversy at my college, Dickinson: https://thedickinsonian.com/news/2015/09/15/photos-draw-anger-apology/

[2] https://www.lexico.com/en/definition/cultural_appropriation

[3] https://attheu.utah.edu/facultystaff/cultural-appropriation-or-appreciation/#:~:text=Cultural%20appropriation%20can%20be%20defined,to%20gain%20knowledge%20and%20understanding.

https://blindinjusticeblog.com/2021/05/03/what-is-cultural-appropriation/

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

The Yukon Harbor Historical Society.

The History of Colby, South Colby, Harper, Manchester, Blake Island, and the Yukon Harbor Area of Washington State & Western Puget Sound.

GRACEFIFTEENTEN

Unleashing the beauty of creativity

Barbie Girl Wonderland

Doll Reviews, Photostories & DIY Adventures

Lluís Bussé

Barcelona's Multiverse | Art | Culture | Science

Life, Entirely

She designed a life she loved...

Kathy by Design

Custom Paper Art for All Occasions

Silent Songs of Sonsnow

"I have enough time to rest, but I don't have a minute to waste". Come and catch me with your wise words and we will have some fun with our words of wisdom.

Inside Insights

reflections on what life gifts you

The Nomadic Architect

An Wandering Monk'ey'

BJDs for Dummies

A page about BJDs for the uninformed

Paper Life Painting

Visual works of Wayne Wolfson

SexPuppet

Continuing Adventures of a New Submissive

Osaka Language Solutions - Japanese Interpreting Services

Professional Japanese Interpreting Services

The Frugal Crafter Blog

Groovy craft projects, crafty recipes and other artsy stuff.

Deb's World

Midlife, fun and adventure

Silicon Valley Types

portraits & figures by an older woman artist, with blue collar roots

All Nudist

Everything about the Nudist/Naturist lifestyle

Penny Berry Quinn's Path

An Adult little girl carrying on with her Daddy in Heaven

Pressvision's Blog

Just another WordPress.com site

Billenkoek

Alles dat je ooit wilde weten over billenkoek...

Adult Second Life Blog

Second Life Blog: Sexy, Adult, Nudy, Sex, BDSM and a lot of more Adult Themes

chapter18

A blog with an Indian prespective

dreamshadow59

A great WordPress.com site

This girl's weblog

of life married to a deviously dominant madman!

Towint

The pagan path. The Old Ways In New Times

This Carbon Based Life

Falling through the universe at the speed of life

exposing40

Friends. Photography. Adventure.

sharechair

Everyday Technology for Everyday Folks

The Geeky Gaeilgeoir

Musings on, and sometimes in, the Irish language

Erotic Musings, Poetry, and Social Commentary

Thoughts, writings, social commentary, and some photography by David Mei. Warning intended for an adult audience if you are not the age of majority where you live, leave now.

Alphabet Ravine

Lydia Rae Bush Poetry

Posy Churchgate ~ Pillow Talk

Fiction with sexual/ adult themes. some non fiction

The Wolf in the Night Sky

A Blogspace for a Daddy Dom

Finding Strength in my Submission

Mature audience only, 18+ NSFW...kinky sex & spankings ahead!

mywildlens

self discovery through photography

Me Against Myself

Let's talk about mental health.

eatliveescape.wordpress.com/

Ingredients for a Beautiful Life!

All about Toni Dolls

For fans of vintage Ideal Toni dolls

Blogable

When it's in your head, it's blogable

After Bella

Addiction Forgiveness Acceptance

The Druids Garden

Spiritual journeys in tending the living earth, permaculture, and nature-inspired arts

Torte - The Blog

Recipes, products and decorating ideas from Torte Cake Decorating Supplies, New Zealand based

The Fat Baby Boomer

Give fat shaming the middle finger using body acceptance and neuroplasticity

Big Cat's Kitty Shed

On what's happening meow

Rohini Kudva

feminism | activism | politics |

%d bloggers like this: